Three benefits of this idea of Genius Hour – 20% Time are that the standards referenced are all ELA standards, the versatility of implementing Genius Hour, and the wide-open grading options for completed projects. I think that the closeness of the idea to ELA standards is the best thing as I am an English teacher who is always how to tie new ideas in with standards to match. This seems to be custom-made for the ELA classroom with all of the research, writing, speaking, and presenting. Add in the digital citizenship and it sounds almost scarily good. The versatility of the Genius Hour -20% Time is also wonderful. Teachers and students can make almost any project work in this instance. Whether it is putting together a class booklet on our town and solving the logistical problems and creative conundrums that come along or creating a new kind of book report with 3-D imaging and presenting it to the whole school, the genius of it is it will work with just about any project at all. The final thought I have about the idea is that grading can be done from almost any angle as long as there is a rubric that clearly delineates how the project will be scored, whether it be mostly on creativity with a nod toward grammar or heavily focused on the writing part of the project. The scoring can be as rigorous as we want or need it to be.
One potential hurdle with the Genius Hour idea is by giving students the freedom to do almost anything at all, we run the risk of one or more students deciding that doing nothing is a good way to spend the time. An idea I had to combat this to not let that become an option. Present the idea of 20% time with the constraint that there must be a project of such a length about a particular issue, problem, or product that the student chooses themselves. If they choose the thing they will be studying, they are less apt to do “nothing.”
Another potential obstacle could be resistance to the idea of such an open plan to education by parents and administration. As the author A.J. Juliani writes, a simple way to sell these groups on the idea is to invite them into your classroom and let them see what the environment is like and maybe get involved in helping the students problem-solve. We could also invite them to the presentations like an old-fashioned science fair but call it a “learning fair” instead.